We’re deep into autumn now, so I’m going to throw out a little-known fact for all you Americans. Up here in the wilds of Canada, we celebrate Thanksgiving in October, and it’s not because we don’t know how to read a calendar.
In 1957, a year close to my heart, Thanksgiving was changed from a random day in November and officially declared to be the second Monday in October.
Giving Thanks in October, especially with our Canadian climate, makes sense for a few reasons:
- Thanksgiving has a harvest theme. What more appropriate time to be thankful than just when the harvest is finishing in many areas.
- Many places are beautiful at this time of year, and that makes it even easier to feel thankful, not only for the harvest, but for the rest of nature’s bounty and just about everything else.
- It’s a lovely time of year to go outside and walk off a big Thanksgiving meal.
- It’s not all that close to Christmas. Hello! Americans celebrate Thanksgiving a mere month before pulling themselves up to another table laden with food, possibly almost identical to the Thanksgiving meal they’ve barely had time to digest.
I’m kidding about #4, of course, but only a little.
The very best thing about Thanksgiving in October is that cooks have time to clean their kitchens of the first Turkey Explosion before embarking on another fowl venture.
Nothing makes me more weary than the thought of getting the bird out of the oven, pulling out the stuffing, cutting the darn thing up (also known as ‘carving’, that beautiful and immaculate thing they do in movies), making gravy, etc. etc. etc., all while directing the mashing of potatoes, and final preps of other traditional goodies. Well-meaning help in close quarters is enough to cause family rifts, and cleaning up the mess that was once a large bird, roasted to golden perfection, has made grown cooks weep.
That’s where I come in. Many years ago my sister shared a recipe for turkey that can be made a few days ahead of the actual event. The only comments I’ve had run along the lines of, “I’ve never tasted turkey this moist before!” and “What do you mean, you made this two days ago?”. Other cooks who have had the nerve to try this recipe say they’ve never had such a relaxed holiday.
Since I have often made turkey for over twenty-five people at Thanksgiving and Christmas, I’ve become a lot less anxious about preparations. Take a look at the recipe below and give it a try if you dare. It’s hard to let yourself break with the “right way” of making a turkey, but I’m so glad I gave it a chance.
STRESS-FREE HOLIDAY TURKEY
(This is for a 20 -25 lb. turkey. Adjust the amount as needed)
4. c. turkey or chicken broth (like Campbells broth in the big tetra-paks)
1/2 c. butter, melted
1/8 c. salt and pepper (mixed)
4 c. water
1 clove garlic, minced (no, you can’t taste the garlic in the finished product!)
1 Tbsp. paprika
DIRECTIONS
1. Put turkey on a rack in large roasting pan.
2. Combine all ingredients and pour over turkey.
3. Bake @ 325 degrees for 4.5 hrs. or until your size of turkey is done, basting several times.
4. Remove from oven, cover, and let sit for 30 minutes.
5. Lift turkey to cutting board.
6. Blend juices using an immersion blender, or do batches in a regular blender. (Let cool first if putting into the blender.) Pour blended juices into a container and set aside.
7. Slice turkey and layer in roasting pan.
8. Retain 2 cups of juice, then pour the rest over turkey in the pan.
9. Cover and put into fridge until turkey day.
TO RE-HEAT
1. Get retained juices out of fridge and put on counter to warm to room temperature.
2. Put turkey into 325 degree oven for about 1 – 1.5 hrs, until heated through, depending on the amount of meat.
3. Put meat on platter and return to oven to keep warm. Pour juices from roasting pan into saucepan.
TO MAKE GRAVY
1. To 2 cups of room temperature broth, add 3/4 c. flour (or more), blending with a wire whisk until it is thick and smooth.
2. Bring broth that was poured off the turkey to a rolling boil, and drizzle in flour/broth mixture in a thin stream, whisking constantly to blend.
3. When gravy reaches desired consistency, stop adding flour/broth and reduce heat to med/low, stirring and simmering for another ten minutes.
DRESSING / STUFFING
(This can also be made a day or two before and refrigerated.)
1⁄4 c. butter, melted
1 onion, chopped fine
2 stalks celery, chopped fine
2 1⁄2 c. milk
2 eggs
1 tsp. Salt
1⁄4 tsp. Pepper
1⁄2 tsp sage
3/4 tsp poultry seasoning
1 loaf bread, broken into small pieces or cut into cubes
- Melt butter in large pot and sauté onion and celery until soft
- Remove from heat and add milk.
- Whisk eggs into milk/butter mixture
- Whisk in seasonings
- Add bread pieces and stir until the liquid is absorbed into the bread. It should be kind of sticky.
Now you have two choices:
BAKING
- Put stuffing into a very well-buttered, appropriately-sized baking pan and cover with foil, OR
- Form stuffing into balls the size of large golf balls and place side by side in a very well- buttered baking pan and cover with foil.
For casserole:
• Bake at 325, covered, for about an 60 – 75 minutes. Check to make sure middle of casserole is steaming hot and cooked through.
For balls:
• Baked at 350, covered, for 30 minutes. Put balls into a bowl and serve.
This sounds delicious and I will keep the recipe on file for the next time I am cooking mine
The only time I ever ever made a whole turkey was last Christmas. It worked fine ..did it the traditional way. But this looks great for any “do it ahead of time” schedule. Or best, if it needs to be taken a distance to eat somewhere else. Turkey can go chilled in a cooler chest, and finished up at the destination. Great idea …..Mom will be happy!!
I can’t see why you couldn’t make the stuffing in the turkey, 2 days in advance, foil wrap it and then stick it back in the oven when you reheat the sliced turkey. It’s my turn for the family dinner this Christmas, and I might just be trying your turkey trick.
Absolutely, Margaret … but with this recipe, the turkey is pretty much immersed in the broth so the stuffing would be yuck. But modify it to suit yourself. That’s what “handy” is all about!
I love the make-ahead part, but I also love that the broth recipe makes lots of luscious gravy for everyone in the crowd.
I just roasted mine. It turned out very well. The juice created by roasting the turkey is going to be a spectacular gravy.